Discussion about this post

User's avatar
John Lawrence's avatar

I have a fair number of Japanese colleagues and friends with whom I talk politics.

This article mixes facts with exaggerations and satire, but several key claims are misleading or inaccurate. A few clarifications:

“Hitler’s Election Strategy” – It is true Takaichi appeared once in an advertisement for the book in the 1990s, but she neither endorsed nor supervised it. She has stated it was a one-off photo shoot and that she never approved the content. Suggesting she actively supported Hitler’s strategy is not factually correct.

Media control – In 2016, as communications minister, she cited an existing legal clause on political neutrality of broadcasters, but no network was ever shut down or lost its license. Japanese media continue to criticize the government openly. The claim that she “turned NHK into Abe TV” is rhetoric, not a proven fact.

Nara deer incident – She did say foreigners mistreated deer, but Nara Park officials clarified they had no evidence of this being routine. It should also be noted that the Japanese police provide guidance in foreign languages to visitors, instructing them not to harm the deer. This shows that the concern arises from actual incidents where deer were mistreated, not purely fabricated claims.

Yasukuni visits – She frames her visits as paying respect to the war dead, not glorifying war criminals. While the practice is controversial, equating it directly with “historical denial” overstates the case. Yasukuni Shrine functions much like Arlington National Cemetery in the United States—a place to honor fallen soldiers. That visits to Yasukuni are treated as an international political issue is itself questionable, as similar acts of remembrance in other countries rarely attract such criticism.

Economic policy – Abenomics had mixed results. While wage growth was slow, unemployment fell and job openings increased. It is incorrect to call the policy a total failure or to dismiss her as “economically illiterate.”

Sanseito alliance – There is no factual evidence that Takaichi has formally allied with Sanseito. As a mainstream LDP figure, she does not rely on such fringe groups.

Democracy in Japan – Despite criticisms, Japan remains ranked as a “full democracy” (EIU Democracy Index 2023, #16 globally). Media freedom has indeed slipped, but largely due to structural and self-censorship issues, not direct government censorship.

In short, the article blends fact with opinion and stretches conclusions beyond what evidence supports. Criticism is fair, but accuracy matters.

I would respectfully suggest that the author conduct deeper research and base the article on verifiable facts rather than exaggerated comparisons. Publishing misleading claims only fuels unnecessary fear among international readers who may not know Japan’s political contexts well.

OmniRabbit's avatar

When I saw one of the expats in my feed refer to this election as "time to find out if the LDP hates women or foreigners more", I didn't really have context for why, and now I do. Thanks for that.

Japan is following all of our own steps, but because it's all happening in comparative slow motion, it doesn't have the same kind of snap back being seen in the US with active constant (and under-reported) protest. I figure the reason the old boys club chose her is the same as Liz Truss - picked a woman to handle what they know is going to be a catastrophe, so may as well distract the feminist cadre by jangling keys in front of their face. I have low expectations, but I can only hope that the slow motion decay becoming fully evident can make even a tenth of the spark that the Anpo movement had all those years ago. History doesn't often repeat exactly, but it does have the same tune...

55 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?